Scoping Review vs. Systematic Review: Which Design Fits Your Question?
Compare review questions, eligibility, appraisal and outputs, with an example of how the same topic can lead to either a scoping or a systematic review.
A scoping review maps the evidence available on a topic. A systematic review answers a defined question by finding, appraising and synthesizing the eligible evidence. Start by deciding what result your readers need.
| Decision | Scoping review | Systematic review |
|---|---|---|
| Question | What research exists and how is it distributed? | What does the eligible evidence say about a specified question? |
| Eligibility | Defines which populations, concepts, contexts and evidence types to map | Defines eligibility around the review question and planned synthesis |
| Appraisal | Include critical appraisal when it serves the objective and explain the choice | Appraise included studies using methods appropriate to their designs |
| Output | Map of study types, measures, populations and research gaps | Synthesis of findings, their limitations and what they mean for the question |
One topic, two questions
For a scoping review, ask How have universities evaluated spaced practice across courses? Chart course types, formats, outcomes and follow-up periods. That map can show whether evidence is concentrated in certain subjects.
For a systematic review, ask Among university students, how does spaced practice compare with massed practice on quiz scores measured at least one week later? Specify the eligible designs and measures before screening. Plan how to explain differences in outcome definitions and whether pooling is justified. A systematic review can use a structured narrative synthesis when studies cannot reasonably be pooled.
Decide before screening
Write the question, search plan and inclusion criteria. Choose the fields you need to chart or extract and decide who will screen the records. Keep a record of any protocol changes. Use PRISMA-ScR for reporting a scoping review and PRISMA 2020 for reporting a systematic review.
LitSynth can help with the title and abstract screening stage and organizing evidence in a table. Plan full-text eligibility, reviewer roles and appraisal explicitly. If your assignment calls for a general review of the literature, start with the worked literature review guide.